Reading Alison Bechdel’s recounting of her estranged relationship
with her father seemed so familiar to me. I wasn’t entirely sure why I felt
this way, at first, but then, it hit me. His cold, detached attitude reminded
me so much of my own father.
Okay, so here’s the short version of my life in relation to
my parents’ ill-fitted marriage.
They met in Med school. My mom’s dad had just died. She was
lonely, and they were both falling for a delusion they mistook for love. They married. And then
they added kids to the mix. Smart, eh?
It was no big secret my father NEVER quite enjoyed the
company of children—something that unfortunately seemed to transcend into his
relationship with his own children. Planned and expected, by my father, I was
referred to as the baby or her baby (subtly abdicating any
responsibility over me to my mother).
I guess I should share
that I have spoken to my father about this. He claims to have felt an immediate
connection to me the day I was born, changing his earlier sentiment. I've always felt torn between what to blame for his behavior: my father’s naturally scientific and
critical personality or his and my mother’s unhappy marriage. Nowadays, I
imagine the latter being the direct result of my father’s impossibly
unemotional demeanor.
Growing up, my father had installed an office space in our
house that was supposed to be restricted to him only. Being the curious, rambunctious
children my little brother and I were, of course we ignored any boundary drawn
around this new space. Both my parents worked a lot, so we took full advantage
of the time we had to explore his work space (that is whenever our nanny didn’t
catch us). The very thought of our chubby, dirty fingers smearing and smudging
his cheap bookcases and outdated Microsoft computer absolutely sent him
bananas.
It would be a careless understatement to simply call him a
neurotic perfectionist.
For years, I wondered
how my father dealt with it. I was always reminding myself of how he slept in the
guest room on the other side of the house. How he yelled at us so often. How he
stormed into his office, locking himself away for the rest of the night. It was
much more difficult to convince myself that underneath his blatant misery, he
loved me.
Bechdel’s depiction of her relationship with her father is
so tragically candid. Every aspect of their interaction is laced with tension.
This does not seem falter, even at his deathbed. She retells of her unusually awkward
interaction with her deceased father. After presenting us with some imagery
referring to her father’s “rough and dry, scraped clean” face (Bechdel 51), “wiry
hair…brushed straight up on end”, and “tiny blue tattoo on his knuckle”, she
then admits to paying her respects for “as long as [she and her brothers]
sensed it was appropriate” (Bechdel 52). Obviously, her disconnected manner of
regarding her father stems from years of mistreatment and neglect and an
unconventional upbringing (as is explored through her sharing of the family
business). Yet, it is on page 86 that I begin to understand why she might have decided to share this story in the first place.
After years of struggling to claw through my dad’s thick
shell in search of some inkling of adoration, I understand what it is to grasp
onto a single strand of hope for connection. The least I can say is it’s gotten
a lot easier to feel something more than the reverberating sound of his office
door slamming on the walls.
I credit that to divorce.
Knowing you as well as I do, I thought this might be an interesting book for you to read, as it also puts what Freud would consider and undo emphasis on the role of the father in a young lesbian's life and development. I know I always tease you about not having the typical "mommy issues" that are so common in lesbians, but this book does a good job on putting that joke in proper context. The relationship between these two characters, father and daughter, is remarkably detailed. The text really does bleed psychology and begs analysis. I read this book before the semester even started and was thrilled with it. It's fascinating to see, rather than just read, about a LGBT character. Honestly, images provide something for me that imagination and text does not. It's a style that I find refreshing, because it allows the reader to relate and internalize the subject matter without having to spend extra time and effort concocting mental images of the situations being described. While I wouldn't choose this genre every time, I think it's a very important addition to the Queer Lit repertoire.
ReplyDeleteWe get to have our own little party over on Gabby's post, whoop whoop! Thank goodness for visuals, I have felt so much more able to delve into the story and turning pages more quickly helps me feel more accomplished. One element that I find interesting from this reading is the very passive way Alison's sexuality is addressed. On page 46, when she reveals her relationship with her girlfriend, she is much more focused on telling the story of her father's death and only briefly addresses that she even has a girlfriend. This manner of address is similar to what one would expect for a heterosexual couple. In this manner, the neutral attitude towards sexuality is reminiscent of Love Conjure/Blues. Also, the stylization through images is quite fun to explore as a reader, and the way Bechdel seemed to embellish some of hers and others' memories, such as that of her father being rescued by the postal worker/milkman, could arguably be classified as 'biomythology.' Overall, the casual, humorous tone made this read all the better.
ReplyDeleteReading Fun Home made me reflect on my own father as well. Much like your father, my dad would be cold-hearted and distant person who doesnt understand the concept of loving father and son relationship. It seems to me that Gabby's father was rather into works or 'workaholic' making himself unavailable to support you emotionally. My father would also be a perfectionist; because of the nature of his work(as a physics professor), he would put a lot of pressure on me and my younger brother from our very young age to succeed and smart. well, I wasn't really the case for him whereas my brother was bright and well-respected by his peers and teachers. I think this is why I hadn't really experienced good connections with him. In page 13, author bechedel writes, "sometimes, when things were going well, i think my father actually enjoyed having a family." It really touched me because my father would turn into a completely different person when I would behave as he wants me to. If I don't, he would literally 'freak out' and kicked me out of the house. I dont think I hated someone as much I hated my dad when he pushed me out the door for three days.
ReplyDeleteThis reading of the first few chapters revealed numerous dynamics that will undoubtedly be explored and explained later in the book, but I was particularly struck by the transference of personality that occurs. It's frightening to observe the direct effects of parental behavior on how their children act, think, and emote. Some aspects, such as the children's lackadaisical attitude about death, could be simply from circumstantial factors (they were surrounded by death in the funeral home). However, I found it very interesting to draw connections between the way the father treated his family and the direct effects on their behavior. The narrator's lack of emotion about very consequential life changes, her slight pleasure in (brief) self mutilation, and the comfort she finds in drugs and alcohol can be, in my opinion, directly related back to her father's actions.
ReplyDeleteI think you captued it perfectly when you talked about looking for any connection possible. I know plenty of people, myself included, who have different issues with their parents, fathers its seems specifically. It can sometimes be so confusing when trying so hard to win the approval of someone I would much rather ignore, and yet I do it everytime without fail, even now. I've even had friends who moved out of the fathers homes, doing anything to get away, and then later confiding in me that they still wished their fathers would have gone after them, even when they would never go back.
ReplyDeleteI'm finding everyones "daddy issues" to be really interesting. Not unfamiliar with this subject myself, I think Bechdel does a great job of showing tension throughout the book without it ever really getting old or becoming a bore. With Bechdels story and everyone else sharing theirs, I'm starting to wonder why is it Fathers that so often are the absent ones whether physically or emotionally? And also how these difficult relationships continue to effect us years after we are long gone from the home of our parents. I heard once that "Childhood is what we spend the rest of your life getting over" and I think this is proving to be true. In the case of Bechdel, I feel like this is very evident. It is easy to see as she tells her life story looking back, that she carries the pain she experienced from the lack of relationship she had with her dad. Not only does she seem cold towards his death, but i feel like in other relationships and stories where he isn't present she comes across as very absent and unconcerned.
ReplyDelete